Attorney AdvertisingServing all of Colorado · Castle Rock office · 720-499-0000 · info@TacticalLawyers.com
Starzynski Van Der Jagt, P.C.Attorneys & Counselors at Law · Tactical Lawyers
Home › Practice Areas › Civil Litigation & Disputes

Civil Litigation & Dispute Resolution

When negotiation fails, you need a clear strategy, honest cost-benefit advice, and preparation. We represent individuals and businesses in Colorado civil disputes.

Where a Colorado case is filed

CourtAmount in disputeNotes
Small claims (county court division)Up to $7,500Simplified procedures; no jury; attorneys are allowed only in limited situations.
County courtUp to $25,000Civil cases, evictions, and some lien matters.
District courtAny amountGeneral jurisdiction, including real-property title, injunctions, and larger claims.
Federal courtFederal questions or diversity over $75,000U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado.

Deadlines

Colorado statutes of limitations vary: generally three years for contract claims, two years for most torts, and three years for many motor-vehicle injury claims, with many exceptions (C.R.S. § 13-80-101 and following). If you’re served with a complaint, you generally have 21 days to respond in district court (C.R.C.P. 12), and the deadline can be shorter in county court. Missing it can lead to a default judgment.

How a lawsuit proceeds

  1. Pre-suit evaluation and demand. Many disputes resolve with a well-documented demand letter.
  2. Complaint and answer, along with any counterclaims.
  3. Disclosures and discovery: Colorado requires early mandatory disclosures (C.R.C.P. 26) and limits discovery in proportion to the case. Simplified procedure (C.R.C.P. 16.1) applies to many claims of $100,000 or less.
  4. Motions, including motions to dismiss and for summary judgment.
  5. Mediation: Colorado courts routinely refer cases to mediation, and most cases settle.
  6. Trial to a judge or jury, then post-trial motions and possible appeal.
  7. Collecting a judgment through garnishment, liens, and asset discovery. Colorado judgments accrue interest.

Alternatives to court

Mediation and arbitration can be faster, cheaper, and more private. Many contracts require arbitration. See our sister site ContractArbitration.us for arbitration and mediation services.

Honest cost-benefit advice

Litigation is expensive and uncertain. We’ll talk candidly about the strengths and weaknesses of your position, likely costs, whether attorney fees can be recovered, and whether the other side can actually pay a judgment.

Disputes we handle

  • Breach of contract and collection of amounts owed
  • Business and partnership disputes, including LLC member and shareholder conflicts
  • Real property disputes: boundaries, easements, quiet title, and co-owner partition
  • Fraud and misrepresentation
  • Construction and contractor disputes
  • Insurance coverage disputes
  • Defamation
  • Injunctions and temporary restraining orders
  • Judgment enforcement and post-judgment collection
  • Defense of individuals and businesses who have been sued

If you’ve been sued: first steps

  1. Note the date you were served and the response deadline. In district court, it’s generally 21 days after service (C.R.C.P. 12). In county court, the deadline is the “answer date” on the summons, and it can be shorter.
  2. Preserve documents and data. Don’t delete emails, texts, or files related to the dispute.
  3. Check for insurance. Your business, homeowner’s, or umbrella policy may provide a defense. Notify your insurer promptly.
  4. Talk with a lawyer before contacting the other side about the substance of the case.
  5. File a response. Usually an answer, often with defenses and counterclaims, or a motion.

Key Colorado statutes, rules, and deadlines

RuleWhat it meansSource
Contract claimsGenerally 3 years.C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(a)
Liquidated debts6 years for a liquidated debt or a determinable amount of money.C.R.S. § 13-80-103.5
FraudGenerally 3 years from discovery.C.R.S. § 13-80-101(1)(c)
Most tortsGenerally 2 years.C.R.S. § 13-80-102
Defamation1 year.C.R.S. § 13-80-103(1)(a)
Answer deadline21 days after service in district court.C.R.C.P. 12(a)
Disclosures and proportionalityEarly mandatory disclosures, with discovery proportional to the case.C.R.C.P. 26
Simplified procedureFor many civil cases seeking $100,000 or less.C.R.C.P. 16.1
Summary judgmentCases can be decided without trial when material facts aren’t in dispute.C.R.C.P. 56
Statutory offers of settlementCan shift costs if a party rejects an offer and does worse at trial.C.R.S. § 13-17-202
Frivolous claimsAttorney fees can be awarded for claims or defenses lacking substantial justification.C.R.S. § 13-17-102
Anti-SLAPPEarly dismissal of certain claims targeting protected speech, with fee-shifting.C.R.S. § 13-20-1101
InterestPrejudgment and post-judgment interest in many cases.C.R.S. §§ 5-12-102, -106

What happens in discovery

Discovery is how each side learns the other’s evidence. It includes written questions (interrogatories), requests for documents, requests for admission, and depositions, which are sworn interviews recorded by a court reporter. We prepare you for every deposition: what to expect, how to listen to the question, and how to answer truthfully without guessing.

Mediation and settlement

Most Colorado civil cases are referred to mediation, and many settle there. A good settlement accounts for the strength of the evidence, the cost of continuing, the time to trial, the risk of an adverse result, and whether a judgment could actually be collected. For contracts that call for private arbitration or mediation, see ContractArbitration.us.

Small claims court in detail

Colorado small claims court (C.R.C.P. 501 and following) resolves disputes up to $7,500 with simplified procedures. The plaintiff files a notice, claim, and summons in the county where the defendant lives, works, or does business, then has it served. The defendant can file a response and a counterclaim (counterclaims above the limit can move the case to county court). Many courts offer mediation on the trial date. Trials are to a judge without a jury, and either party may appeal to the district court on the record. Attorneys may appear only in limited situations, so preparation is key: organize documents, photos, and witnesses, and bring copies for the court and the other side.

Collecting a judgment

  • Judgment liens: recording a transcript of judgment with the county clerk and recorder creates a lien on the debtor’s real estate in that county.
  • Garnishment: wages and bank accounts can be garnished, subject to exemptions that protect part of the debtor’s earnings and certain property.
  • Post-judgment discovery: interrogatories and examinations under C.R.C.P. 69 require the debtor to disclose assets.
  • Duration: district court judgments can generally be enforced for up to 20 years, and county court judgments for 6 years, with revival or renewal possible in some circumstances (C.R.S. § 13-52-102).

Injunctions and emergency relief

When money damages aren’t enough, for example to stop a former partner from using trade secrets or to keep property from being sold, courts can issue temporary restraining orders and preliminary injunctions (C.R.C.P. 65). The party seeking relief generally must show a reasonable probability of success, a danger of real, immediate, and irreparable injury, no adequate remedy at law, that the balance of equities favors relief, that relief serves the public interest, and that it preserves the status quo. Courts usually require a bond.

Appeals

Appeals from district court go to the Colorado Court of Appeals, and the notice of appeal is generally due within 49 days of the final judgment (C.A.R. 4). Appeals from county court go to the district court. An appeal reviews the record for legal error; it isn’t a new trial.

Preparing for trial

Few cases go to trial, but preparation for trial drives fair settlements. Trial preparation includes final witness and exhibit lists, the trial management order required in Colorado district courts, motions about what evidence the jury may hear, jury instructions, and preparing each witness to testify. A jury trial requires a jury demand and fee. In district court, a civil case is generally tried to a jury of six unless the parties agree otherwise. We explain each stage so you can make informed decisions about settlement and risk.

What to bring to your consultation

You don’t need everything on this list to get started. Bring what you have, and we’ll help you get the rest. Please bring copies, not originals.

  • The summons and complaint, or the demand letter you received, with the date you were served
  • The contract and any amendments, invoices, and payment records
  • Emails, texts, and letters with the other party
  • A timeline of key events
  • Insurance policies that might cover the claim
  • Any prior court orders or judgments

Costs and fees

Your first 15-minute consultation is free. After that, the fee depends on the matter. Depending on what you need, we may offer a flat fee, hourly billing against a retainer, or limited-scope (“unbundled”) help for a defined task. Litigation is usually billed hourly against a retainer, with budgets discussed up front. Some matters may qualify for limited-scope help, such as coaching for small claims. Some contracts and statutes allow the prevailing party to recover attorney fees. The scope and fee are always set in a written engagement agreement before work begins, and we’ll talk candidly about likely costs, such as filing fees, service of process, transcripts, and outside witness or appraiser fees, so there are no surprises.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Missing the response deadline. A default judgment can be entered against you.
  • Destroying or “cleaning up” evidence. Courts can impose serious sanctions for spoliation.
  • Suing without checking whether the defendant can pay. A judgment you can’t collect has limited value.
  • Ignoring an arbitration clause. It may control where and how the dispute is decided.
  • Posting about the dispute online. It can create new claims, such as defamation, or undermine your case.

Related guides and pages

Frequently asked questions

Do I need a lawyer for small claims?
No. Small claims is designed for people to represent themselves, and attorneys may participate only in limited situations. A lawyer can still help you prepare.
I was served with a lawsuit. What now?
Note the response deadline (often 21 days in district court, and possibly less in county court), preserve documents, and talk with a lawyer right away.
Can I recover my attorney fees if I win?
Only if a contract or statute provides for it, or in limited situations such as frivolous claims. Many contracts include fee-shifting clauses.
How long does a civil lawsuit take?
Many Colorado district court cases take about a year or more to reach trial. Small claims and county court cases are usually faster. Settlement can happen at any stage.
What does litigation cost?
It depends on complexity, the number of witnesses, discovery, and whether the case goes to trial. We provide a budget estimate and update it as the case develops.
What is a deposition?
A sworn, recorded interview by the opposing lawyer. Your lawyer attends, can object, and prepares you in advance.
Can I represent my business in court?
In small claims, a business can appear through certain officers or employees. In county court, closely held entities can be represented by an officer in limited circumstances. In district court, entities generally need a lawyer.
What if I win but the other side doesn’t pay?
Colorado provides tools such as garnishment, bank levies, judgment liens on real estate, and post-judgment discovery of assets.
Should I accept an offer of settlement?
Consider the risks of trial, the costs, and, under Colorado’s offer-of-settlement statute, the possible cost-shifting if you do worse at trial than the offer.
Can I appeal a small claims decision?
Yes. Either party can appeal to the district court, which reviews the record of the small claims trial. Deadlines are short.
How do I collect a judgment from someone who won’t pay?
Common tools include judgment liens on real estate, wage and bank garnishments, and court-ordered disclosure of assets. Some property is exempt from collection.

This page is general information about Colorado law as of November 2026, not legal advice for your situation. Laws and figures change; talk with an attorney before acting.

Talk with a Colorado attorney

Start with a free, no-pressure 15-minute consultation by phone, video, or in person.

☎ Call 720-499-0000Free Consultation